Instagram Soundcloud Spotify

The Tits, The Teeth and The Trauma Of The Swan: Behind the Mirror

Written by:

Over eighty years ago, E.B. White wrote this about television: “I believe television is going to be the test of the modern world, and that in this new opportunity to see beyond the range of our vision, we shall discover a new and unbearable disturbance of the modern peace, or a saving radiance in the sky. We shall stand or fall by television—of that I am quite sure.”

This weekend I watched a documentary profiling a show that disturbed the modern peace.

And it did it with collagen and rhinoplasty.

Let’s go back to early spring of 2004 when I was taking an online journalism class through my community college and the assignment was to do a review of a movie, book, or new TV show.

I had just heard of a new reality show called The Swan, so I thought I’d give it a shot.

I made some popcorn, took out my notebook, and started to watch. It took no time at all for it to become a train wreck. I couldn’t take my eyes off the screen. The premise of the show was to take “plain” women and make them into “swans,” using Viaplastic and dental surgery, extreme weight loss, and God knows what else. The “ducklings,” as they were called, had no access to mirrors, so they couldn’t see themselves. After three months, their new look was revealed to them while they were wearing a ball gown and Diamonique jewelry. Of course, the duckling-turned-swan would see herself in the mirror and start to cry.

And cry.

And cry.

And cry.

She would then dab her eyes and thank everyone for their hard work.

And then there was a beauty pageant.

In other words, if she was starting to feel better about herself, here was a chance to feel awful over again.

I sat there thinking, This is bad. Bad, bad, bad. Bad moon rising, bad to the bone, bad company. I looked at my notes. Mostly I had written down “procedures done” “bullied” and “WTF.” Somehow I wrote a review, worried they were going to take away my admission to the liberal arts women’s college I was accepted to if they found out I was watching this dreck.

I somehow blocked The Swan from my memory, but this weekend I saw The Swan: Behind the Mirror on Hulu, and it all came back to me. Plus, it reminded me yet again that reality TV isn’t TV.

The documentary shows the women who were on both seasons of the show (yeah, there was a second season) and what they experienced during their “journey.” It was a long humiliating list of plastic surgeons marking up their faces, a steady diet of Jenny Craig-prepared food (oh, what a shocker: Jenny Craig was a sponsor!), being bullied to lose weight, being pushed physically, and participating in a beauty pageant, and a swimsuit and lingerie competition they were never told about.

The whole thing made the Miss America pageant look like a feminist collective.

The former swans seemed sad and embittered about what happened to them and several of the women have had health issues due to the extreme surgeries they endured. Despite this, some of the people who worked on The Swan upon being had a totally different take. One producer even recalls getting choked up seeing the first Swan being crowned. “That’s why I want to do shows like that,” they said. “If you can have an impact to help…”

Help who?

None of the women have any love for the show’s creator, Nely Galan. They spoke about how it felt knowing that Galan genuinely didn’t want them to do well. When one woman gained weight and then came back to do an appearance for season two, Galan was not a happy camper. She said in front of everyone, “What happened to you?” and then placed her in the back row for subsequent appearances. In an irony of ironies, Galan posted a picture of her with Gloria Steinem on her Instagram feed after Steinem died, writing: “One of the greatest women of all time has passed, Gloria Steinem. Lit from within, a one-of-a-kind true heroine. Read her books and experience an incredible life and a true mission to empower women. This Ms. will never be forgotten.” I debated writing: “You really skimmed Ms. Steinem’s books, didn’t you?”

I wish the documentary did more of a deep dive into why The Swan was such an initial hit. The show was escapism pure and simple; after all, weeks after its debut, photographs of torture at the Abu Ghraib prison had been released to the public and U.S. forces had begun an attack on Fallujah in Iraq.

No wonder people wanted to see pretty ladies in their evening gowns with pretty new teeth and big boobs. Real life was simply too much.

Gaby Wood of The Guardian got it right when she wrote: “…the winner on The Swan is the woman who is thought to have undergone the greatest ‘overall transformation’ — in other words, the one who appears least like her former self.”

Gillian Flynn of Entertainment Weekly added the show was, “…a misogynistic mix of TV’s twin vices: commercialism and conformity.”

Not that you needed it, but The Swan; Behind The Mirror is a friendly reminder that reality TV has nothing to do with reality, and the show itself was a disturbance to the modern peace, for sure.

And many women are still paying the price for that disturbance twenty-two years later.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *